Dunstan Legal



Email Us Today
for a consultation

  • Home
  • Areas of Practice
    • Wills & Estate Planning
    • How to Make a Will
    • Contesting a Will
    • Executors & Probate
    • Powers of Attorney
    • Civil Disputes & Litigation
    • Business & Commercial
    • Conveyancing in New South Wales
    • Selling Property
    • Buying Property
    • Business Purchase/Sale
    • Business Succession
  • Blog
  • Contact Us

Can I Get Security For Costs If The Other Party Appeals Against My Judgment

October 13, 2020 by Dunstan Legal

This situation arose recently for our client who had obtained a judgment in the Supreme Court against the defendant.  The defendant did not pay the judgment amount and lodged an appeal in the NSW court of Appeal.  This meant that even though our client had spent a considerable amount of legal costs already, he was being put  to more expense defending the appeal.  The defendant claimed to have no assets in her name and very little money in her bank account but at the same time had stated that she could get money from her husband whenever she liked.  Our client applied for the defendant/appellant to be ordered to pay into court an amount from which he could recover his costs of the appeal if her appeal was unsuccessful.  In order to obtain security for costs against the defendant our client was required to show special circumstances beyond the mere fact that the defendant/appellant had no money.  His Honour Justice McFarlan found that there was an “essential unfairness” constituting “special circumstances” if any judgment could not be enforced against her whilst at the same time she had the means, by request to her husband, to obtain funds to meet such expenses as she wished to pay.  His Honour found an essential unfairness in the defendant/appellant being immune from enforcement when at the same time she had ready access to funds to pay her lawyers in the appeal and also in other non-related proceedings in which she was involved.  Consequently, the court ordered that the defendant/appellant pay an amount into court as security for the costs of the appeal and the application for security for costs of the appeal.

The judgment is available at the following link

https://www.caselaw.nsw.gov.au/decision/1750bbc1f1e523935948f38a

Filed Under: Blog, Civil Dispute & Litigation

Online Enquiry

.

    Our Focus

    • Experienced
    • Deal with the Principal directly
    • Wide range of services

     
     
    Dunstan Legal Logo

    Our Advantages

    We bring a strategic approach to achieve outcomes drawing on decades of expertise and experience in almost every area of the law. This gives us a very broad knowledge base and panorama of experience to draw upon when navigating towards successful outcomes.

    Areas of Practice

    • Wills & Estate Planning
    • How to Make a Will
    • Contesting a Will
    • Executors & Probate
    • Powers of Attorney
    • Civil Disputes & Litigation
    • Business & Commercial
    • Conveyancing in New South Wales
    • Selling Property
    • Buying Property
    • Business Purchase/Sale
    • Business Succession

    Contact Us

    • Suite 302a, Level 3, 20 Bungan St, Mona Vale NSW 2103
    • PO Box 984 Mona Vale NSW 1660
    • DX 9034, Mona Vale NSW 2103
    • (02) 9997 7200
    • (02) 9999 4667
    • [email protected]

    Connect with us

    • Email
    • Facebook
    • Phone

    Copyright © 2022 · Website hosting by Lift Legal Marketing · Log in